1 (2) IUSTITIA 13 (1973)
I start with the concession that much of what Professor Hook says is true. Not to recognize this would be folly. Hook's condemnation of academic violence is necessary, justified, and important. Ultimately, however, the picture he draws and the conclusions he states are misleading.
Academic freedom is indeed in jeopardy, but not merely from the internal sources Hook mentions. Outside pressures exist as well. Professor Hook suggests that by establishing a criminal law system, universities can successfully cope with student violence. Having been involved at almost every level of the internal judicial process at the university, I am convinced such a system is not a viable solution.
Getman, Julius G.
"A Comment on Professor Hook's Paper,"
IUSTITIA: Vol. 1
, Article 3.
Available at: http://www.repository.law.indiana.edu/iustitia/vol1/iss2/3