Document Type
Note
Publication Date
Spring 2026
Publication Citation
101 Indiana Law Journal 999
Abstract
More than half a century ago, in the landmark case of Graham v. Richardson, the Supreme Court held that the Equal Protection Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment prohibits state-level blanket exclusions of noncitizens. That case ushered in a new rule: State classifications based on alienage are “inherently suspect” and subject to strict scrutiny. But Graham’s rule has a major exception. Just a few years after Graham was decided, the Court upheld several state laws excluding noncitizens from working as police officers, public school teachers, and probation officers. So was created what would later be termed “political function” doctrine. This exception has nearly swallowed the rule. Today, states across the nation bar noncitizens, regardless of their lawful status, from performing certain civic functions and from working in various professions. These laws have been almost uniformly upheld under the “political function” exception. This Note tells the story of how this exception came to be. And it argues that the “political function” exception should not be understood as an exception. Instead, it should be understood as a doctrine for surviving strict scrutiny, pulling it back in line with Graham’s original rationale, so that the promise of Graham still means something.
Recommended Citation
Anderson, Charles J.
(2026)
"The Hidden Power of Citizenship: Political Identity in the Twilight Zone of Equal Protection,"
Indiana Law Journal: Vol. 101:
Iss.
3, Article 7.
Available at:
https://www.repository.law.indiana.edu/ilj/vol101/iss3/7
Included in
Civil Procedure Commons, Civil Rights and Discrimination Commons, Courts Commons, Fourteenth Amendment Commons, Immigration Law Commons, Jurisprudence Commons, Law and Society Commons, Public Law and Legal Theory Commons